Meta Knowledge for Extending Diagnostic Consultation to Critiquing Systems
نویسنده
چکیده
Critiquing systems check for weaknesses in the user's solution and may suggest corrections. Although their usefulness was first emphasized in diagnostic domains [6], the main success of knowledge based critiquing systems have been in design applications [4, 13]. While in the latter a deep understanding is often not necessary for critiquing purposes, in complex diagnostic domains the capability to solve the problems is critical for critiquing systems. However, they need additional knowledge to adjust to the user's solution instead of merely inferring solutions by themselves. We analyze that knowledge and propose a minimal model for extending a diagnostic consultation to a critiquing shell.
منابع مشابه
Concepts for a Diagnostic Critiquing System in Vague Domains
Since the seminal work of Perry Miller about medical critiquing systems in the eighties, there has been remarkable little further research. We present a knowledge level analysis of the types of knowledge and reasoning strategies necessary for an diagnostic critiquing system in vague domains. Instead of building a critiquing system from scratch, we investigate how to enrich a knowledge-based dia...
متن کاملCritics: An Emerging Approach to Knowledge-Based Human-Computer Interaction
We describe the critiquing approach to building knowledge-based interactive systems. Critiquing supports computer users in their problem solving and learning activities. The challenges for the next generation of knowledge-based systems provide a context for the development of this paradigm. We discuss critics from the perspective of overcoming the problems of high-functionality computer systems...
متن کاملA Collaborative Development Environment for Design-Oriented Critiquing Systems
Design–oriented critiquing systems have successfully demonstrated their capability to aid users in designing artifacts. They can be seen as personal assistants helping to reflect on a particular design and to improve it. For doing so, design–oriented critiquing systems make knowledge and expertise of domain experts available to end users of authoring tools. Unfortunately, it is a quite demandin...
متن کاملEnabling Medical Expert Critiquing Using a Bdi Approach
Expert critiquing systems were introduced to assist physicians in decision making, without forcing them to comply to a gold standard of care. Critiquing systems do this by providing critique on a physician’s decisions, rather than telling him/her exactly what to do. In order to perform this task, a critiquing system must have knowledge of the diagnosis and the treatment processes, and must be a...
متن کاملCoffein: Construction and Presentation of Design Knowledge
Design is a hard problem: ill defined and open-ended. Schön [Schön (83)] characterized the process of designing an artifact as a successive refinement of reflection and redesign. Critiquing the communication of reasoned opinion about an artifact plays a central role in the design process. A computational critiquing mechanism provides an effective form of human-computer interaction to support th...
متن کامل